AAAI 2027 Review Timeline and Rebuttal Guide (October 19 Author Feedback Window)
A source-backed guide to the AAAI-27 review season: the post-Phase-1 stages, how to use the October 19-25 author feedback window, preparations before the November 30 decision, and camera-ready formatting.
Updated 2026-10-27 · AutoSCI Team
Direct answer
AAAI 2027 is in review season: Phase 1 rejection notices went out on September 24 (no notice means your paper advanced to full review), the author feedback (rebuttal) window runs October 19-25, final decisions arrive November 30, camera-ready files are due December 14, and the conference meets February 16-23, 2027 in Montréal, Canada. Submission formats and length limits for the feedback window follow the official OpenReview instructions.
The full AAAI-27 timeline
| Milestone | Date |
|---|---|
| Abstracts due | 2026-07-21 (passed) |
| Full papers due | 2026-07-28 (passed) |
| Supplementary material and code | 2026-07-31 (passed) |
| Phase 1 rejection notice | 2026-09-24 (sent) |
| Author feedback (rebuttal) window | 2026-10-19 – 10-25 |
| Final accept/reject notification | 2026-11-30 |
| Camera-ready due | 2026-12-14 |
| Conference | 2027-02-16 – 02-23, Montréal |
What stage are we in?
The author feedback window closed on October 25. Papers with submitted rebuttals are now in final review: the next milestone is the November 30 accept/reject notification. The three most valuable things to do while waiting: pre-format the camera-ready per the commitments made in your rebuttal, get supplementary material into a releasable state, and plan for the December 14 camera-ready deadline and the February 2027 Montréal conference.
How to use the feedback window effectively?
General best practice (official rules prevail):
- Respond point by point: number and address every major comment from every reviewer; nothing left unanswered.
- Clarify before contesting: most negative comments stem from misreading — politely restate the concern as you understand it, then answer with evidence from the paper.
- Be restrained with new experiments: a small addition (one ablation, one baseline) is fine; large-scale new results are usually unwelcome and look rushed.
- Correct factual errors directly: wrong section references or misquoted numbers deserve a courteous, explicit correction.
- Keep it short: a crisp response beats a paper-length defense.
What to do while waiting for November 30?
- Pre-format the camera-ready: AAAI's format has been stable in recent years — 7 pages of main text (references excluded), two columns, 10 pt Times New Roman body, 1-inch top/bottom and 0.75-inch left/right margins, abstract ≤ 150 words, a mandatory Ethics Statement, and the official AAAI citation style (AuthorKit). Follow the latest official AuthorKit.
- Prepare supplementary updates: if the rebuttal promises changes, get code and data into a releasable state early.
- Rehearse the talk (if applicable) and plan the February trip to Montréal.
What if my paper was rejected in Phase 1?
A Phase 1 rejection is not a verdict on the work's value — it is usually an initial screen on fit or significance:
- Revise substantively (especially on "the selling point is unclear") and target the next cycle: ICML, NeurIPS seasons, or AAAI 2028.
- Avoid resubmitting the identical manuscript elsewhere immediately.
A fill-in template for point-by-point responses
A reusable structure for each individual comment (one paragraph per comment, numbered to match):
- Understanding: one sentence restating the reviewer's concern as you read it ("We understand your concern about the scalability of X").
- Clarification / evidence: point to the specific data or passage in the paper ("Table 2 in Section 4.2 shows …") — most misunderstanding-type comments end here.
- Addition (only when necessary): one small new result (a single ablation or baseline), clearly labeled as new.
- Commitment: state exactly where and how the revision addresses it ("revised on page 5 to …").
- Thanks (optional): one measured sentence for constructive comments.
Matching strategy for the three common cases: misunderstanding → clarify with evidence; valid criticism → acknowledge and commit to a revision; factual error → correct it politely and directly with a reference. Keep the tone objective throughout — the response is read by the area chair as much as by the reviewer.
A 10-minute checklist before the feedback window
- Every reviewer's comments numbered and organized?
- A clarification mapped to each misunderstanding, citing the paper?
- Added experiments small and necessary?
- Tone professional, never combative?
- Response format matching the current OpenReview instructions?
- Data and figure references accurate?
- Spelling and grammar checked?
- A buffer left before the deadline?
Save time: an AAAI template is ready
When preparing the camera-ready or a transfer submission, AutoSCI's AAAI conference template is available online, aligning the two-column layout, the 7-page rule, and the AAAI citation style automatically. 中文版:AAAI 模板。Spend your rebuttal time on content, not formatting.
References and official sources
Sign up free — let AutoSCI handle the formatting
Register to use every journal and conference template online — upload your paper and AutoSCI aligns the layout, figures, and references automatically.
FAQ
When are AAAI 2027 results announced?
Final accept/reject notifications arrive November 30, 2026. Phase 1 rejections went out September 24, the author feedback window runs October 19-25, and camera-ready files are due December 14.
When is the AAAI 2027 rebuttal period?
The author feedback window ran October 19-25, 2026 (now closed). Final notifications arrive November 30 and camera-ready files are due December 14; authors who missed this cycle can target the next one (AAAI 2028, or the ICML/NeurIPS seasons).
What does it mean if I received no Phase 1 notice?
The September 24 notice went only to papers rejected in Phase 1; no notice means your paper advanced to full review, and you can prepare for the October 19-25 feedback window.
What are AAAI's camera-ready format requirements?
Recent stable rules: 7 pages of main text (references excluded), two columns, 10 pt Times New Roman, abstract ≤ 150 words, a mandatory Ethics Statement, and the official AuthorKit template and citation style; the latest AuthorKit prevails.
How long should each rebuttal response be?
One paragraph (3-6 sentences) per comment: one sentence of understanding, one or two of clarification with evidence, an optional small new result, and a revision commitment. Short and precise beats lengthy self-defense — the response is read by the area chair as much as by the reviewer.
What should I prepare before the window opens?
Three things: a numbered list of all comments, response drafts in the understanding → clarification → commitment structure, and any small supplementary experiments ready to cite. AAAI's window lasts only seven days (October 19-25) — drafting in advance is the only calm way to play it.
Only a few days are left in the rebuttal window — is it too late to start?
This cycle's window closed on October 25; late submissions are not possible. If you still have the reviewer comments, turn them into a revision checklist for the manuscript itself — the same numbered-list + point-by-point template prepares you for the next cycle's rebuttal.
I missed the AAAI 2027 rebuttal window — what now?
The window is closed and late submissions are not accepted. Two paths: wait for the November 30 decision (misunderstanding-type comments rarely decide the outcome on their own), and if the paper is ultimately rejected, turn the reviews into a concrete revision checklist and resubmit in the next cycle (AAAI 2028, ICML, or NeurIPS).
